Two AI tools can read the same files and give different answers. Before deciding one is better, give both the same task and the same files, and write down everything else that differs between them.
One gave a better answer. Isn’t that the comparison?
One run on one question shows a difference exists. It doesn’t show why, or whether it will happen again.
1. Keep the test the same for both.
Files. The same version of each file.
Task. The same written request, word for word.
A good answer. A list of what it must contain, such as the passages, the calculations or the layout, written before either tool runs.
2. Write down what differs between the two.
Note who is signed in and what they can open, the model, and which tools and sources are switched on. Any of these can change the answer, so a difference in the result may have nothing to do with how well each tool reads a file.
3. Check each answer four ways.
- Did it leave anything out?
- No required section is missing without a note saying so.
- Do its references back it up?
- The passages it points to say what the answer says.
- Did it use the right policy and dates?
- The right version, period and group of people.
- Can someone use it as it is?
- The output is usable, and it’s clear what to do when it fails.
Practical check: Repeat the cases that matter most. One run can differ from the next.
A fictional comparison: one leave policy question.
- First setup
- Covers every section and points to the right passages, but uses last year’s policy.
- Second setup
- Uses the current policy and leaves out the section for part-time staff.
- What differed
- The second could open the current policy folder and the first couldn’t.
- Next step
- Give both the same folder and run the question again.
4. Decide what to do with the result.
Keep what you have, give the tool a smaller task, or change tools. Weigh the quality of the answers against who can use each tool, how updates are controlled, what it costs to run and who supports it.
Read more: Should You Switch When a New AI Model Comes Out? · Build, Buy or Configure? Choosing an AI Solution · How to Test an AI Agent With Questions It Hasn’t Seen
The comparison is fictional and the checks are an example. One run doesn’t show how reliable a tool is. This is general guidance, not advice for your situation.